Middle Island Pizza

Reviews about Middle Island Pizza

• 1 / 5

  By Erika F
  Horrible service! I called ahead of time, thinking I wouldn't have to wait. I arrive, pizza was ready I'm thinking OK cool! I hand the man my credit card. He swipes and all of a sudden remembers the machine is broke. Its going to be about a ten minute wait for it to kick back with a confirmation stating it didn't go through. I explain to him that my boyfriend has to be at work in 30 minutes. His attidude showed he could careless, he even suggested to write down the credit card info and he will bill me. I looked at him as if he had 3 heads? As a professional running a business why would that be the only solution? After I declined his offer and decided to call my bank to see if I got charged because at this point between the way I was treated and the long wait I didn't even want the pizza!! He rushes out to my car knocks on window and states it went through. No apologies nothing! My bill came out to $41. 38 (approximately) Even if he offered me a small salad for the inconvenience he caused me and my boyfriend he did not! It gets much better I get home and its the wrong order!! Pissed at this point we called and was told to bring back the pizza and they will make the right order. I was overcharged as a few days later I grabbed a menu to look it over. No way two pies cost $41 dollars!! I just left it alone and decided to never ever eat there, tell my friends about my experience and write this review. 1 star is still being too nice. Sorry but not sorry! First time last time!! Plain old rude!!!
  May 18, 2017
• 2 / 5

  By Joe Recchia
  I love there food and we order from them all the time and not once was my order been right when the guy answers the phone. He never knows were anything is on the computer they use and puts u on hold after item u order. And then he gets upset when u tell if its for delivery. Hate to say it but if he picks up the phone i just hang up now. They need to give him something else to do.
  December 20, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By George Jensen
  Great pizza and dinners with a beautiful new dining room. Great pasta specials eat in during the middle of the week. Fast home delivery. Try the deserts
  August 15, 2016